“Darling, I Love You But Give Me Park Avenue”

by Jamison Koehler on August 27, 2014

We live on Park Avenue.

It is a beautiful tree-lined street in an historic part of town.  But it is not what you think:  It is not Park Avenue in New York City.

And that is because we live in Baltimore.

That is the thing about this city.  For every street, bridge, monument, or tourist attraction, there is a street, bridge, monument or tourist attraction somewhere else that is better known, more famous. Do you think of Baltimore when you think of Penn Station or Park Avenue?  Of course not. You think of New York City. How about Pennsylvania Avenue or the Washington Monument or Key Bridge?  No, those things are all associated with D.C. And Mt. Vernon, of course, is in Virginia.

I have to be careful when I say this because I do want not to offend my brother-in-law George.  George grew up in Baltimore, and, like most natives, he takes any perceived slight of the city very personally.  For example, you can’t even mention John Elway’s name without aggravating George.  (When the Baltimore Colts drafted Elway with the very first pick in the 1983 draft, Elway reportedly said he would rather be a garbage collector than play for the city.  This forced the Colts to trade him for a fraction of his value.)  In fact, that used to be my test for determining whether a person was a true native of Baltimore:  I would ask the person what he or she thought of Elway.  If the person did not share George’s passionate dislike of Elway, I would know that I had unmasked a poseur.

On New Year’s Eve two years ago, George and I stood with my sister and my wife in the living room of their house in Grosse Pointe, Michigan.  My wife and I had already made the decision to move to Baltimore, and we were thinking very seriously about Roland Park, which is where George had grown up.  But, as my wife put it, we wanted to live somewhere where we would be able to walk to things, and my sister suggested we consider Bolton Hill.  George was skeptical.  After all, Bolton Hill was near some pretty questionable areas the last time he had lived here.  But I saw the look in my wife’s eye when my sister suggested this.  George, I said to him.  I have a strong feeling that’s where we are going to end up.

And end up there is what we did.

It has been a good move.  I love the sirens and the back stoops, the cracked pavement and the graffiti.  I love the sidewalk cafes and the $2 Natty Bohs at Turps, the local sports bar where you can order the best BBQ wings in town.  And you can’t beat the rumble of the commuter train during the day or the screeching of the rails of the freight train late at night.

My wife and I chose Baltimore not despite The Wire but because of it.  And we moved to Baltimore not because we had grown up here or because we had family here or even because we had jobs here.  (My wife has a national practice and I commute every day to D.C.)  No, my wife and I moved to Baltimore out of pure love for the city.  And there cannot be many people who can make this claim.  Not even George.

More like this:

They Make Me Wear This Jersey

We Used to Live in the Steinberg House

The Permanence of Blue

{ 0 comments }

My Real (and Not So Real) Heroes

by Jamison Koehler on August 19, 2014

Guest Post by Somers Brush

I normally tell people that my desire to be a lawyer came after the couple of weeks I spent with my aunt and uncle during the summer before my senior year of high school. I shadowed my Aunt Susan and watched her in action during one of her trials, and I admired her presence in the courtroom. I still enjoy following her enormous feats in her career and one of my biggest accomplishments in college so far was arranging for her to come and speak to a group of students at Middlebury.

During my time in Virginia that summer, my Uncle Jamie drove me to Susan’s temporary offices in Alexandria every day, and he told me a lot about his own experiences as a lawyer. One of the things I remember most was our drive to the airport at the end of the week. He explained to me what his strategy was going to be in one of his cases. The young teen he was representing was guilty but sympathetic, and although I do not remember the exact details, I do remember how impressed I was with Jamie’s line of thinking, with his creativity as he was building his argument. So, yes, my interest in the law was definitely sparked by two of my incredibly impressive family members. But what I don’t normally reveal is that if I’m being honest, part of the reason I want to be a lawyer stems from my love of television.

My sister Emma has noted in the past that I sometimes get fact confused with fiction. For example, during a discussion about the trials of raising a child with autism, I stated in all seriousness, “Yes, that has been very difficult for Adam and Kristina” (referring to one of my favorite shows, Parenthood). The characters of Friends feel like my actual friends, and too often someone will say something that reminds me of a joke that Chandler made, and I will chuckle to myself, thinking, “Oh, Chandler.”

So, I think when I saw the courthouse and all the lawyers with their briefcases and the judges in their robes, I was reminded of the drama and excitement of courtroom shows like The Good Wife. This was the case once again when, as a summer intern, I observed the Assistant U.S. Attorneys in action at the federal courthouse in Detroit. When I imagine myself as a litigator, I definitely aspire to be like Susan Burke and Jamison Koehler. I also aspire to be like Alicia Florrick and Diane Lockhart. Alicia wears the classiest outfits and there is something deep and measured about Diane’s voice that makes you hang onto her every word.

This combination of talented lawyers and actors has made my future clear in my mind. But on more than one occasion, people have told me that they can’t picture me as a lawyer; that I’m too sensitive, that I’m not confrontational enough, that I’m too “nice.” This bothers me. For one thing, it’s rude. I literally just said that I was considering going to law school. And you’re going to respond by telling me that I would be a terrible lawyer? Okay. On another note, anyone who says that doesn’t know me very well. Or they don’t understand people in general. Yes, I am smiley and empathetic and I do have a tendency to cry when I get overwhelmed or when I watch movies like The Fault in Our Stars.

But different roles are appropriate for different situations. For example, during our annual Koehler family reunions at Cape Cod, I am quieter than I would be amongst my group of friends in college. And I like it that way; I feel that for the time being, that is my role as one of the younger cousins. I enjoy listening and observing and admiring. And I know that my aunts, uncles, and cousins understand that this is not all that I am. With my mom, dad, brother, and sister, I am often too loud. I am always the one who yells for my brother Jared to come down to dinner when he has his headphones on in his room and can’t hear anyone else but me. I don’t know how I do it, but if I want to, I can project my voice to a painfully loud decibel. Seriously, ask my parents about it. They will probably cringe as they nod. My point is that as three-dimensional human beings, no one is just one thing. There are different parts of us that appear at different moments. And the qualities that a person presents in his or her particular trade are not all the qualities that that person necessarily possesses.

The last reason that it bothers me when my peers shut down my dreams is the fact that although we are well on our way to becoming fully grown, we are not quite there yet. At the age of 20, I know I have plenty more to learn. There are books I have yet to read, papers I have yet to write, crises I have yet to experience; there is plenty of time to learn how to turn my strengths into passions. I am in constant awe of the attorneys at the U.S. Attorney’s Office, and the reason for this is because they have knowledge and skills that I don’t. I am in awe of the combination of creativity and logic that comes with being a lawyer, the ability to make critical points by asking a series of questions, the confidence it takes to stand in front of a judge and a jury.

I know I am not that person yet, not even close. (An AUSA in the General Crimes Unit made this fact abundantly clear. Before a presentation for the interns, someone asked him if we were all law students, and he said, “Yes, everyone except for HER!” He lifted up his arm and pointed at me. And kept pointing. And kept pointing.)

But that’s kind of the point. Some day I would like to be the person I am in awe of right now. Matthew McConaughey was once asked in an interview who his hero was, and he replied that his hero was himself in 15 years. Although he sounded arrogant when he said that, I think his response was actually rather humble. He aspires to be someone he is not right now. Although he thinks he can be that person in the future, he acknowledges he is not there yet, that he has room to grow. And if you think about it, it makes perfect sense. Why wouldn’t we want our future, older, wiser selves to be our own personal heroes?

I mean, maybe I will decide that I don’t want to be a lawyer. Or maybe I won’t get into a single law school. Or maybe I’ll get into a top tier law school but fail the bar seven times and be forced to accept my failures and move on with my life. Or maybe I will pass the bar, but I will realize that I am a terrible lawyer and decide to do something else. Who knows?

But right now, I look at all the lawyers I admire, like Jamie, Susan, Alicia, Diane, and the civil rights AUSA whose conversations I always listen in to because she talks very loudly. And I think to myself: That could be me someday. But in my own, unique way, because after all, it’s me we’re talking about.

* * *

 The author (pictured in the Vermont countryside) is a political science major at Middlebury College. She is studying at UCL in London in the fall. Over the summer she interned at the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Detroit. She loves her Uncle Jamie very much and plans to follow his footsteps to law school (albeit a littler earlier in her career than he did).

{ 1 comment }

Judge Easterly Lets The Facts Speak For Themselves In Damning the Government for Brady Violations

August 1, 2014 Evidence

You suspect it happens all the time:  the prosecutor withholds exculpatory information from the defendant, thereby preventing the defendant from mounting an effective defense.  The problem is that, with the government in sole possession of all the information, you have no way of proving it. And then there is Vaughn v. United States, __ A.3d […]

Read the full article →

“Equal Justice Under Law”: Why Alec Karakatsanis Is Not Your Typical Smug, Humorless Public Interest Lawyer

July 30, 2014 D.C. Superior Court

One of the hazards of public interest work is that it seems to contribute to smugness.  I may be underpaid and overworked.  But at least I am doing the Lord’s work.  And that work is more important than anything my higher paid colleagues with more prestigious jobs are doing. I encountered a little bit of […]

Read the full article →

“Observe and Report”: The Duties of Fake Cops

July 24, 2014 Humor

This is what the witness’ duty is.  It is not to “protect and serve” like a regular police officer.  Instead, it is to “observe and report.” The judge isn’t sure she heard this right, and she asks him to repeat it.  He doesn’t flinch.  He obliges. I have some fun with this on cross. So […]

Read the full article →

Who Wants To Be The Last Person Arrested for Possessing An Ounce Of Marijuana In DC?

July 18, 2014 Current Events

With the Marijuana Possession Decriminalization Amendment Act of 2014 having gone into effect yesterday, the Washington Post did an article today discussing the fate of the last few people who were arrested under the old law.  (From now on, possession or transfer without payment of one ounce or less of marijuana will be a civil […]

Read the full article →

The DUI Defense Lawyers Association: A New Challenge to the NCDD

July 16, 2014 DUI and Driving Offenses

I am clueless about the politics. But you know this has to be a really, really bad thing for the National College for DUI Defense (NCDD). Justin McShane hinted that something was up at the most recent meeting of the NCDD in New Orleans when he announced that his presentation that day would be his […]

Read the full article →

Judicial Notice: The Difference Between “Legislative” and “Adjudicative” Facts

July 14, 2014 Evidence

A court accepts a well-known and indisputable fact without taking the time and trouble of requiring a party to prove it.  What could be more straightforward, more commonsensical, than that?  As McCormick puts it, the “oldest and plainest ground for judicial notice is that the fact is so commonly known in the community as to […]

Read the full article →

Wayne LaFave on “Motive”

July 13, 2014 Legal Concepts/Principles

Motive.  It is really big on TV shows.  At the same time, if you listen to Wayne LaFave, it is completely irrelevant when it comes to substantive criminal law:  The government is not required to prove motive in order to secure a conviction. The New Oxford American dictionary defines “motive” as “a reason for doing […]

Read the full article →

Actus Non Facit Reum Nisi Mens Sit Rea

July 13, 2014 Legal Concepts/Principles

Translated into English, actus no facit reum nisi mens sit rea means that “an act does not make one guilty unless his mind is guilty.” In other words, it is not enough for the government to prove a physical part of a crime; that is, an act or an omission to act.  The government must […]

Read the full article →